US Populace Doesn't Understand Satire

2011-03-07 14:00:44 by chort

I've been noticing a trend lately. The people participating in online "communities" these days are so blinded by the perceived inherent rightness of their beliefs that they are unable to see how their opinions are viewed by others.

This first struck me in an obvious way as I was wasted a perfectly good night on Youtube a few weeks ago. I got sucked-into The Key of Awesome. It's a Youtube channel that parodies pop music (fairly well, in my opinion). The creator often reads feedback on camera, most of which is facepalm-inducing. Most of the criticism goes along the lines of "dear so-and-so, I really love most of your videos, but the one about [my favorite artist] was totally ignorant! [my favorite artist] is awesome, and the fact that you made fun of them shows you don't understand their genius!"

What the hell is wrong with these people that they think any artist could be so perfect as to transcend criticism, or even caricature? They apparently have no concept of the difference between an opinion and a fact. Aside from that, if you can't even chuckle when someone adeptly roasts your idol, you have some real insecurity issues.

Another example of this can be seen in the Retarded Emails section of The Oatmeal comic. Apparently you can pick any arbitrary topic as the basis for your comedy and people will hate you for it, regardless of the obvious lack of seriousness.

This all makes me think: The massive push in the last 20 years to value self-esteem over any objective measure of merit has convinced each kid that their opinions are the only thing in the world that matters, utterly oblivious that every other human being in the world also has an opinion. We need to be teaching kids how to objectively evaluate themselves in the context of the world around them, or we are in for a future that makes Charlie Sheen look like a thoughtful critical-thinker.